This is a shorter comparison series as it only compares 2 polishes but I had to do it when I realised how alike they are!
Maybelline Brocades in knitted gold is an exact dupe for Ciate Antique Brooch in the bottle and on the nail
The pink glitter in the Maybelline may be slightly larger than Ciate, but for half the price it’s worth the switch! Ciate is on my ring finger for hose who can’t tell the difference!
They both have a similar wear time too, so I’d definitely recommend the switch to the cheaper brand on this one.